When the sew-along live stream began Saturday afternoon, I had my fabric ironed and was all ready to cut my dress out. Pretty quickly however, I realized a couple minor alterations would be needed to make the dress fit my personal preferences.
First off, the pattern had no side seams, so I wouldn't be able to add my standard side-seam pockets to it. I don't do dresses without pockets, so this needed to be addressed. I briefly considered adding patch pockets to the dress, but decided against in. I really wanted side-seam pockets. Thus, I cut the circle skirt over-skirt pattern in half, adding a side seam.
Able to proceed with my pockets like normal, I moved on to the next pattern alteration. The skirt for the under-dress pattern was very straight, and I was afraid it wouldn't cover my back side. So I used the slash and spread method to add some extra fullness to the back of the under dress.
Pattern alterations done, dress cut out, it was on to the sewing. That Saturday afternoon I got the basic construction of the dress done, and put it on my dress form to let the circle skirt stretch for at least 24 hours.
On Sunday afternoon, I had other plans so was unable to watch the sew-along and finish my dress. Thus, it stayed on the dress form until Wednesday evening, when I finally had time to work on it again. First I checked the circle skirt hem. To my surprise, no stretching had happened so no even-ing up was required. That was nice.
As I watched part 2 of the sew-along I hemmed the circle skirt with a narrow double-turned hem and the underskirt with a wider double-turned hem.
Hems done, it was on to the binding. Nearly the entire dress is finished with double-fold bias tape. Originally, I was going to use whatever pre-made bias tape I had in my stash which looked decent with my dress fabric. The bias tape which fit the bill was lime-green. It would have worked. . . but I decided it wasn't quite what I wanted.
For some reason, I had "pink" stuck in my head, so I went through my fabric stash, found a 1/3 yard remnant of quilting cotton in the correct shade of pink, and made my own bias tape.
The pattern called for 3 packages of double-fold bias tape, but didn't tell me how many yards that translated too. So, I pulled out a package of bias tape from my stash, saw that it was 3 yards, hoped that was the standard size for a package of bias tape, and took it to mean I needed to make 9 yards of bias tape for my dress.
After cutting the entire 1/3 yard remnant into 2" wide bias strips, sewing them end-to-end I had just over 8 yards of bias tape. I hoped that would be enough, proceeded to press it into double-fold tape and sewed it to my dress.
I applied the bias tape entirely by machine. (There was no way I was hand sewing the binding all around the entire dress. Visible top-stitching was fine in my opinion.) 8 yards was more than enough. I have pink bias tape left over, even after going the extra mile and binding the raw edges of my pockets in bias tape.
The hemming and bias taping was the most time consuming part of making this dress, and I got it done while watching part 2 of the sew along.
Next up it was time for the closures! I'd intended to sew on the closures while watching part 3 of the sew-along, but life got in the way. So, I took the dress with me to work instead and sewed on buttons, hooks, and eyes while helping children with their school work. (Yes, I am still working, even with the world shut down due to Covid 19. Child care is essential.)
The under-dress fastens in the back with a single button and loop. I made the button loop out of a small elastic pony-tail holder.
The center front of the dress fastens with hooks and eyes.
I alternated the hooks and eyes on either side of the opening for a nice secure closure. (Just like I did on my German Renaissance gown last fall.)
Once the hooks are done up, the front of the dress lies nice and smooth - and there's no way the hooks will come undone on their own.
Once the last hook was sewn on, the dress was done!
I wore it last Sunday. Even though the world is shut down, it made me happy to get dressed up. Physically going to church isn't a thing right now, but wearing a dress to online church in my own living room helped to make things feel a bit more "normal".
So, with that, what do I think of this dress?
I've definitely read quite a few blog posts and reviews of this pattern, and every single one of them mentioned multiple fit issues, and highly recommended making a mock-up and a bunch of pattern alterations.
The week before the sew-along, Marika posted a video showing her alterations and mock-up of the pattern.
And yet, I decided to skip the mock-up and alterations and just sew up the dress. I've made a bunch of patterns and am aware of how Butterick patterns generally fit my body, so this seemed like a relatively safe option for me.
I picked my standard size in Butterick patterns - which is one size smaller than my measurements would indicate I need based on the Butterick size chart. (Standard as in the size I generally pick for this pattern company, not my store dress size.)
This was absolutely the right decision size-wise, as the finished dress fits well.
Once of the most common complaints I read online about this dress is that the weight of the circle skirt would drag the dress down in the back, pulling the front of the dress up - especially on smaller busted ladies, the under-bust fastenings in the front wouldn't stay under the bust.
Well, I am definitely not small-chested, so I figured the size of my bust would do it's job in keeping things in place.
It did. The dress stays fastened exactly where it should, no getting dragged toward the back at all.
As for the alterations I did make, the pockets turned out just as beautifully as I'd hoped!
However, I wish I'd done something a bit different with the underskirt. It is just too straight for my hips and likes to migrate upward while I'm wearing the dress. The under dress is all one piece, fitted with darts and no waist seam. I think I might cut it off at the waist, thus adding a waist seam, and replace the too-straight skirt with a more A-line one. I believe this alteration would take this dress from "nice, I'll wear it occasionally, but too annoying to wear often" to "a go-to every day dress I love". Now I just need to actually make the time to replace the underskirt,
And so, that is my Walk-Away dress, made with Butterick 4790.
I am thrilled to have finally gotten around to making this dress!
Thank you, Marika, for hosting the sew-along and motivating me to actually do it!
